Affinity Fish: Why This Dundas West Omakase Is Toronto's Worst-Kept Secret

Location: 1581 Dundas St W, Toronto
Price Point: $150 (12-course omakase) + 20% service fee
Reservations: Required via Tock
Hours: Thursday–Saturday evenings only

There's a fish shop on Dundas West that transforms into one of Toronto's most compelling dining experiences three nights a week. No signage advertising dinner service. No flashy Instagram-bait plating. Just two chefs with 25 years of combined experience, a rotating menu of wild-caught Canadian seafood, and execution that makes you wonder why you've been paying more elsewhere.

The Space

The dining area is intimate—twelve seats maximum, situated in what functions as a working fish shop during the day. The setup is completely intentional: Jon and Matt (the chefs and owners) started this as a fish monger specializing in Canadian waters, then began hosting pop-up dinners to showcase their catch. Two years later, they're basically running a full restaurant, though they'd probably resist calling it that.

The intimacy works in your favor. You're close enough to watch prep, hear the chefs discuss each course, and understand that this isn't theater—it's a team that genuinely respects fish showing you what happens when you handle it right.

The Winter Menu

January's omakase focuses on what Canadian waters offer when it's freezing out. Sounds counterintuitive, but winter is actually when fish are at their fattiest and shellfish are at their sweetest—they're storing energy for the season. Jon and Matt know this and build the entire menu around it.

The meal opened with whitefish shinjo stuffed into fried shiitake mushrooms. Delicate fish mousse, earthy mushrooms, proper texture contrast—simple but executed perfectly. White miso soup with sansho and simmered turnips came next, resetting everything before the sushi progression started.

Then it got serious: Salt Spring Island mussels cooked in nitsuke. PEI bluefin tuna that was noticeably fattier than what you'd get in summer. Pickled Lake Huron cisco—yes, from the Great Lakes, and yes, it absolutely holds up. Haida Gwaii albacore. Wara kunsei otoro (smoked fatty tuna) that was borderline obscene. Twelve courses total, each one showcasing a different Canadian fishery.

The rice was seasoned correctly. The wasabi was fresh, not the fake green paste. The fish was handled with respect—no over-manipulation, no unnecessary garnishes trying to do too much. Just excellent protein, and properly prepared rice.

Why It Actually Works

Most omakase in Toronto takes the easy route: import fish from Japan, follow the standard playbook, charge accordingly. Affinity Fish does neither. The Canadian sourcing isn't performative—it's literally the entire point. Jon and Matt have direct relationships with fishers across the Great Lakes, Atlantic, and Pacific coasts. They're practicing ikejime (the Japanese technique for immediately bleeding and chilling fish to preserve quality) on Canadian species that most people assume aren't "omakase-worthy."

The result? Seafood that legitimately tastes better than what you'll get at most high-end sushi spots, often at a lower price.

The sake program deserves mention too. Kaja, their sake sommelier, runs the pairing menu ($95 for six courses) and actually knows what she's talking about. It's optional, but if you're already committing to the experience, do it. My favorite was the final pour—a sake that somehow tasted like banana, which sounds insane but worked perfectly.

The Real Numbers

$150 for twelve courses is competitive. Add the 20% service fee and you're at $180 before drinks. Sake pairing brings you to roughly $295 before tax. Is it expensive? Sure. Is it worth it? Absolutely. You're paying for quality fish, skilled preparation, and an experience that feels personal rather than transactional.

How to Actually Book This

Reservations are required and book out 2-3 weeks in advance. The Thursday-Saturday schedule is firm—this is still a functioning fish shop during the day, so the retail operation dictates when dinner happens. Menus rotate based on season and what's actually available, which means January's lineup won't be what you get in June.

Whether you're taking clients, celebrating something, or just want exceptional fish, this works. The space is small enough to feel intimate without feeling stuffy or overly precious.

Bottom Line

Affinity Fish is doing something specific and doing it exceptionally well. They're not trying to be the most expensive or the most Instagrammable omakase in the city. They're two chefs with a clear vision, sourcing incredible fish from Canadian waters, and executing at a level that most places charging significantly more can't match.

In a city where most high-end sushi relies on imported ingredients and established formulas, finding something this thoughtful and this good is rare.

Book it before the secret's fully out.

Reserve Intel:

• - Book 2-3 weeks ahead via Tock
• - Sake pairing worth the upcharge
• - Winter/early spring = fattiest fish season
• - Max 12 seats—intimate by design
• - Parking on Dundas; 505 streetcar accessible

‍